« Really? | Main | Look who's going to be on Bones!! »
April 30, 2008
He's still here
When will they finally send David A home? When can we all stop the suffering? Will it be this week when all the Boston Red Sox fans completely freak out over his butchering of Sweet Caroline? And why don't the judges ever criticize him? His voice cracked, he closed his eyes (again!), he made bond-headed melodic changes to well known tunes and the closest we get to criticism is Simon calling him clever. And you know that Simon meant he was choosing a song to save himself, not that it was a good performance--kind of like Kristy Lee's God Bless the USA choice way back when. Gah. Go home already.
Jason - I love you dude. I will buy your CD and I download your performances every week. First song was better than the judges gave you credit for. Second song was ok. But here's the thing--Jason isn't meant to sing this themed AI drivel. Let him choose his own song and he will rock. Let him play some Jack Johnson or Josh Radin and he will blow everyone off the stage. Remember Over the Rainbow? I hope he gets through this week so he can get a chance at a song that doesn't make him cringe.
Brooke - Creepy. That's the only word I can think of to describe that first song. It was like some bizarre children's party performance and one that would have made all the kids cry. Nightmare was exactly right.
David Cook - He won weeks ago and just proves it over and over. Careful though. I think the combover is creeping back a bit.
Syesha - I like her. I just don't think she should win Idol. She did well again last night. She has a great voice. But...she belongs on Broadway. And don't get me wrong, I love me some Broadway so it's not an insult. I just don't want to see her win here. So if she goes home, I won't be too upset.
Bottom two:
Jason and Brooke. It's a toss up who will go home. Hopefully the little tween voters will keep Jason around long enough for us to hear him do something in his genre.
Ultimate shake up? Send home friggin' David A. How great would that be. dialidol has him in the bottom three. It could happen, yes?
Posted by michelle at April 30, 2008 09:29 AM